Andrew and Shelby's engagement took place in Savannah, Georgia, at The Forsyth Fountain. Andrew had spent hours scouring Google Earth to find the perfect spot to propose, and chose the sunny day they arrived in Savannah to ask Shelby to marry him. On their walk to the fountain, Shelby's new shoes started to hurt her feet, but Andrew urged (begged!) her to keep going. They finally arrived at the fountain, where Andrew asked a random family of nearby tourists to take their picture. As they posed in front of the fountain, Andrew turned to Shelby and popped the question. Shelby said yes, and the couple was thrilled to be engaged and married at a location that holds a special place in their hearts.